The Myth Versus the Reality of Adam Smith’s Political Economy

With the current economic climate, there has been much discussion about the origins of the financial crisis and the future of capitalism. In these typically hollow debates, Adam Smith is routinely and thoughtlessly invoked as the founder of modern capitalist though, based on unrestrained trade, limited government, and the mechanics of market economies. To this day, The Wealth of Nations is held up as the espousal tome for free-market ideology that decries government regulation, excessive taxation, and wealth redistribution (in whatever contrived shapes it may take).

But the myth of Adam Smith created by two centuries of advanced industrialization and capitalism is very far from the reality of Adam Smith. The majority of academics and pundits alike generalize on Smith’s observations about the invisible hand, the benefits of division of labor, and the growth of wealth through free trade.

Outside of these points, The Wealth of Nations serves as an of his time reaction to the impact of corporations and mercantile interests on economies and governments. More specifically, Smith spent much of his book reacting to the growth of the East India Company, whose stockholders were to be found on every level of government decision making in Great Britain and thought to be adversely effecting foreign policy and internal financial systems. Smith was also appalled at the exploitation under the reign of the East India Company, including the starvation of over 30 million people in modern-day Bangladesh due to British-imposed tariffs.

As Chomsky notes, Smith saw the East India Company and other stockholding corporations as bending state policy towards the good of the few at the expense of the many. Smith to this end was in favor of heavy-handed government regulation to prevent financial and corporate powers from manipulating government policy for their own ends. This led him to conclude on the nefarious impulse of corporate manipulation, that when “People of the same trade seldom meet together, even for merriment and diversion, but the conversation ends in a conspiracy against the public, or in some contrivance to raise prices. It is impossible indeed to prevent such meetings, by any law which either could be executed, or would be consistent with liberty and justice. But though the law cannot hinder people of the same trade from sometimes assembling together, it ought to do nothing to facilitate such assemblies; much less to render them necessary.”

The legacy of Smith continues to diverge further and further from the reality of Smiths principles which were heavily influenced by Rousseau and other humanist figures of the Enlightenment. Smith advocated for a system of progressive taxation and a political economy centered on the freedom of creative pursuits but protective of the working class. Considering how his legacy is enshrined today, it seems out of place to realize that Smith’s chief concern was for economic policy to be secondary to moral and ethical concerns such as economic equality, freedom of speech, and dignified and just labor conditions.

See Also: Was Adam Smith a liberal?, Justin Fox’s new book: ‘Myth of the Rational Market’, “The Hottest Places in Hell are Reserved for Those Who, in Times of Moral Crisis, Maintain a Neutrality”, How the financial crisis has killed the governance reform agenda, A Fleecing Of The Sheeple, Another Comment on Bonuses and Benchmarks, Taking Stock: Economy and Government, and Now Lemme Tell You A Story, The Devil He Has a Plan.

[tags]adam smith, the wealth of nations, free markets, economics, capitalism, taxation, government regulation, evaluating smith’s legacy, what adam smith really believed, political economy, corporate influence, government[/tags]

Email

0
From The PBH NetworkHot On The Web
  1. bbk says:

    Let’s not forget the pesky little thing known as social contract theory, which was Adam Smith’s justification for a progressive tax system. Smith clearly did not believe that the rich have earned their wealth through their own hard work. Today’s idealogues would call Smith a Communist had he been alive today.

  2. […] On the Mythology of Adam Smith’s Political Economy: prosebeforehos […]

  3. thepoetryman says:

    “Considering how his legacy is enshrined today, it seems out of place to realize that Smith’s chief concern was for economic policy to be secondary to moral and ethical concerns such as economic equality, freedom of speech, and dignified and just labor conditions.”

    Indeed…

  4. Härj says:

    The conspiracy quote is actually in the game Civilization IV as an illustration of guilds, lol.

  5. […] Also: The Myth Versus the Reality of Adam Smith’s Political Economy, The Immorality of High Taxes, and Dead Ideas […]

  6. YeahRight says:

    Did you read it? Do you understand the free market? Smith makes a lot of sense and he is completely for a free market. A free market doesn’t mean no government regulation. It means the government and the corporations are separate. It means the government doesn’t distort the market through things like subsidies. It also means that the government very strongly intervenes in protecting the rights of the individuals. The type of regulation is key here. Nice try, but this article is just silly.

  7. stryga says:

    It appears the author of this article has not spent much time with “Wealth of Nations.” Smith’s argument was the exact opposite of “heavy-handed government regulation;” he believed that only through a divestment of government and the market could a market serve the needs of the people.

    Smith recognized that when government is in a position to regulate an economy it is in a position to dispense economic favors. The very passage that the author quotes is a discussion on how government should neither hinder nor facilitate when it comes to the market. This is why people point to Smith as a champion of free-market economics.

  8. Bob says:

    Missing word: The Wealth of Nations serves as an of his time reaction

  9. Bob says:

    Smith also believed that either globalization or free markets had a limited life span of around 200 years before the market went to hell. There are some essays on this online but I’m too rushed to go look for them.

  10. Hugh says:

    So Smith was against the government giving special favors to corporations. That makes him a “free market ideologue” by most definitions.

  11. Bob says:

    Hello? Where have the comments all gone?

  12. alec says:

    The comments are right here?

  13. Anonymous says:

    but what happened?

  14. Anonymous says:

    The quote chosen is one of the better points made in the book, but it is taken completely out of context. Smith was discussing guilds, which were similar to the labor unions we have now. A blacksmith’s guild would ensure that new blacksmiths had apprenticed under a master blacksmith (guild member) before going to work. They would also petition the government to obtain monopolies in certain geographic areas. If anything, in the above quote, Smith was arguing AGAINST government-created monopolies on certain professions, not in favor of government regulation.

  15. […] The Myth Versus the Reality … […]

  16. […] talk about Adam Smith implies that he was some kind of a Gordan Gecko greed is good type guy, which couldn’t be farther from the truth.Please share and Enjoy:If you're new here, I'd recommend checking out the about me section. Thanks […]

  17. kevin777 says:

    You are taking Adam Smith out of contex. You might want to read his works.

  18. mudanzas internacionales…

    The Myth Versus the Reality of Adam Smith’s Political Economy…

  19. Trading Forex Gratis…

    The Myth Versus the Reality of Adam Smith’s Political Economy…

  20. much easier to remember how the domain…

    is written and if you use a keyword, it will get you ranked high in search engines. your domain name may contain a popular domain extension such as.com/.co.uk/.in/.net/.org most bloggers prefer this because it makes the blog look professional with a…

  21. that everything will be the same because…

    we all speak english. it isn’t. there are subtle differences between canadians and americans. there are even greater differences between an american’s more distant english speaking relations in great britain, south africa, the west indies, new zealan…

  22. of the best ways to grow your…

    business and drive a lot of traffic. people spend hours on blogs reading posts but there are a few tips to having a good blog and driving a lot of traffic. below i am going to go over exactly how to…

  23. free ipads says:

    {You should|You need to|You ought to|You must|It is best to|You’ll want to|It’s best to|Make sure you|You might want to|It is advisable to|You really should} {check|verify|examine|check out|test|look at|take a look at|investigate} this out…

    Online sites of curiosity we have now a hyperlink to…

  24. {Cool|Awesome|Great|Amazing|Interesting|Neat|Fascinating|Trendy|Nice|Wonderful|Fantastic} {sites|websites|web sites|internet sites|web-sites|web pages|online websites|online sites|webpages|internet websites}…

    we came throughout a neat web-site you might relish. Consider a glance in order for you…

  25. {Visitor|Customer} {recommendations|suggestions}…

    one in all our prospects just lately advised the next web-site…

  26. {Blogs|Weblogs} ou {should|ought to|must|really should|need to|should really|will need to|should certainly|have to|may want to|should preferably} be {reading|studying|reading through|looking at|examining|looking through|browsing}…

    Here is often a Awesome Blogging site You could possibly Locate Appealing that we Really encourage You…

  27. Take a look at this out…

    that is the finish of the content. Right here you’ll find some web pages that we believe that you will take pleasure in, just simply click the one-way links through…

  28. free xbox says:

    Weblogs ou should really be reading…

    Here is really a Superb Web site You could possibly Obtain Interesting that we Motivate You…

  29. Sources…

    examine below, are some entirely unrelated internet websites to ours, in spite of this, they can be most dependable sources that we use…

  30. Gems type the on-line world…

    highly very few internet sites that take place for being thorough beneath, from our point of view are unquestionably properly value looking at…

  31. Susan Donofrio…

    Generally I don’t read drug wherefore blogs….

  32. Herb Cirillo says:

    Louvenia Zaborski…

    Approximately I don’t read article on blogs….

  33. Louvenia Zaborski…

    More or less I don’t read drug whereupon blogs….

  34. Great web pages…

    consistently a giant enthusiast of linking to bloggers that I love but don’t get a lot of backlink adore from…

  35. Hyperlinks…

    Internet sites of desire we now have a website link to…

  36. Salvador Cochrum…

    we came throughout a great site which chances are you’ll acquire satisfaction in. Require a research at the time you want…

  37. Gems with the world wide web…

    rather couple internet sites that occur to become comprehensive down below, from our perspective are definitely effectively definitely worth checking out…

  38. Dreary Day…

    It was a dreary day listed here today, so I just took to messing all over on the internet and discovered…

  39. Salvador Cochrum…

    we arrived across a interesting blog which you will get enjoyment in. Take a look for as soon as you want…

  40. Dreary Day…

    It absolutely was a dreary day the following today, so I just took to messing about on the web and found…

  41. Quickest way to burn off stomach excess fat extremely fast…

    Any when within a whenever we choose for weblogs that we look over. Detailed beneath will be the most the latest web pages that we decide for…

  42. free xbox says:

    Dreary Day…

    It had been a dreary day here at present, so I just took to messing around on the web and uncovered…

  43. Web sites really worth going to…

    here are a few one way links to webpages that we website link to because we think they’re value traveling to…

  44. Awesome web sites…

    we arrived across a neat internet site that you could possibly like. Just take a look if you need…

  45. Examine was captivating, remain in contact…

    please visit the web pages we go along with, as well as this an individual, due to the fact it represents our picks through the web…

  46. Gems from your web-based…

    exceptionally several webpages that transpire to become specific beneath, from our viewpoint are certainly well worth checking out…

  47. Irvin Canela says:

    Awesome web site…

    the time to read through or explore the website content or web pages we now have linked to down below the…

  48. Online websites really worth checking out…

    right here are some inbound links to web-sites that we website link to considering we believe that they are really truly worth going to…

  49. Deja Tuell says:

    Cool web sites…

    we came throughout a cool information site that you may possibly like. Take a look if you want…

Hot On The Web